Compare: The Plaza vs The Knickerbocker
Choose 2–4 hotels. The table uses averages of the prices printed on each hotel's own menus.
The PlazaThe Knickerbocker
Side by side
| Metric | The Plaza | The Knickerbocker |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Midtown Manhattan, New York, NY | Times Square, New York, NY |
| Menus | 7 | 6 |
| Dishes & drinks | 182 | 216 |
| Breakfast avg | $31.06 | $27.50 |
| Starter avg | — | $25 |
| Main course avg | $51.76 | $40.04 |
| Dessert avg | $27.33 | $11.30 |
| Cocktail avg | $34.78 | $26 |
| Room service | YesBreakfast 6am-11am; all day 6am-11pm; overnight menu | Yes24 hours; breakfast 6-11am, lunch & dinner 11am-10pm |
| Room service avg price | $41.59 | $21.52 |
| Bar closes | 11pm | 10pm |
| Vegetarian / vegan / GF | 8 / 6 / 0 | 7 / 1 / 4 |
| Price range | $12–$370 | $0.50–$219 |
| Price level | $$$$ | $$$ |
| Cuisine | American | American |
| Menu types | Breakfast All Day In-Room Dining Afternoon Tea Afternoon Tea Cocktails Kids | Breakfast All Day Dinner Dinner In-Room Dining Happy Hour |
Same dish, different hotel
| Dish | The Plaza | The Knickerbocker |
|---|---|---|
| Burger | $44.00The Plaza Wagyu Burger | $31.00The Knick Burger |
| Caesar salad | $32.00Caesar Salad | $13.00Caesar Salad |
| Pancakes | $15.00Central Park Pancakes | $25.00Buttermilk Pancakes |
| Eggs Benedict | $38.00Eggs Benedict | $29.00Eggs Benedict |
| Omelet | $62.00The Plaza Royal Omelet | $29.00Three Egg Omelet |
| Avocado toast | $34.00Avocado Toast | $25.00Smashed Avocado Toast |
| Wings | $32.00Chicken Wings | $26.00Jumbo Chicken Wings |
| Salmon | $54.00Seared Faroe Islands Salmon | $10.00Lightly Cured Faroe Island Salmon |
| Ribeye | $58.00Prime Ribeye Steak | $98.00Black Angus Ribeye |
| Filet | $82.008oz Prime Filet Mignon | $76.00Black Angus Filet Mignon |