Shelter Island – Shelter Island, New York: Shelter Island HeightsPhoto: Hayden Soloviev · CC BY 4.0

Hotel Dinner Menus in Shelter Island, NY

1 hotel in Shelter Island, NY publish a dinner menu in our guide. Across them, the average listed dinner item costs $34.90. Each link opens the hotel's page at that menu, with hours, prices and map.

1 hotel with menus in Shelter Island

  1. Sunset Beach

    Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island, NY

    $$$$ · Mains avg $63.13 · 70 items

    All DayCocktails

    Sunset Beach dinner menu · Sunset Beach Restaurant & Bar · 42 items · avg $34.90

    Open every day but Tuesdays for lunch and dinner

    Quick route